Quarterly Cheese Club
*Our Winter Club will begin shipping the week of December 4th.
These are a few of our favorite things: rainy days and cozy nights; celebrating and giving thanks with loved ones near and far; and sharing memorable moments over delicious, crave-worthy cheeses. Our Winter Club features cow and goat milk cheeses ranging from fresh to firm to triple cream to eat-this-one-with-a-spoon luscious. We hope this assortment warms your hearts — and bellies!
$15 shipping fee (FedEx Overnight Shipping). Item cost and shipping fee are per shipment. This item is a recurring quarterly subscription.
Holiday Order Deadlines:
Christmas: order by Tuesday, 12/19 at noon to ship Wednesday
Cowgirl Creamery | Petaluma, CA
Cultured Butter - Fresh Pasture - Mushrooms
An organic American original cheese recipe, our best-selling cheese has all the lusciousness you expect from a triple cream with a unique heart that upholds its texture. Named after the iconic landmark Mount Tamalpais that rises over the San Francisco Bay in Marin Country, Mt Tam cheese is produced with organic, locally-sourced milk and rises above the standard for bloomy rind cheeses. Mt Tam takes you from fudgey firmness to buttery softness with flavors spanning from bright creme fraiche to complex and mushroomy, evoking the North Bay’s lush green and gold pastures.
Organic Pasteurized Cow’s Milk, Microbial Rennet (Vegetarian) - 7 oz
Suggested Beverage Pairings: Sparkling Wine, Dry Cider, Drinking Chocolate
Suggested Accompaniments: Sweet snacks (preserves, honey, etc.)
Cypress Grove | Arcata, CA
Tart - Citrusy - Perfectly balanced
Perfectly cultured milk, pure and simple — the building block for Cypress Grove’s entire line of cheese. At Cypress Grove, they take enormous pride in clean milk from carefully managed dairies, and that care and attention to detail has a huge impact on the final cheese. Tart, tangy, and perfectly balanced with no “goaty” aftertaste in sight, Ms. Natural is the perfect expression of fresh goat cheese.
Pasteurized Goat’s Milk, Microbial Rennet (Vegetarian) - 4 oz
Suggested Beverage Pairings: Wheat beers, lambics, prosecco, sauvignon blanc
Suggested Accompaniments: Pistachios (or your favorite nuts), citrus jams (like Frog Hollow!), roasted vegetables, apples, pears, figs
Point Reyes Farmstead Cheese Co | Point Reyes Station, CA
Heat - Umami - Nutty
The rich texture and buttery flavor that makes Toma a true American original blended with heat, umami, and nutty flavors. The key to the flavor is Shichimi Togarashi, a Japanese spice blend containing chili flakes, nigella, chili powder, orange peel, ginger powder and nori. The result is a gentle heat that warms your palate gradually, making you want more!
Pasteurized Cow’s Milk, Microbial Rennet (Vegetarian) - 6 oz
Suggested Beverage Pairings: Pilsner, Japanese-style beer, gin & tonic
Suggested Accompaniments: Mexican food, charcuterie
Jasper Hill | Greensboro, VT
Woodsy - Sweet Cream - Button Mushroom - Spruce-Wrapped
A pocket-sized version of Jasper Hill’s classic Harbison, a soft-ripened cheese with a rustic, bloomy rind. Young cheeses are wrapped in strips of spruce cambium, the tree's inner bark layer, harvested from the woodlands of Jasper Hill. The spoonable texture begins to develop in their vaults, though the paste continues to soften on the way to market. Harbison is woodsy and sweet, balanced with lemon, mustard, and vegetal flavors.
Pasteurized Cow’s Milk, Traditional Rennet (Non-Vegetarian) - 5 oz
Suggested Beverage Pairings: Oaky white wine, barrel-aged sour beer, apple cider
Suggested Accompaniments: Fruit mostarda, crusty bread
Meyer Lemon Marmalade | Frog Hollow Farm | Brentwood, CA
Frog Hollow’s very untraditional (but exceptionally delicious!) Organic Meyer Lemon Marmalade is bright and tangy without the bitterness of other citrus marmalades. The mild and fragrant Meyer Lemon is milder than its usual lemon counterpart, which makes this marmalade a perfect choice for a marmalade. You can tell that they take incredible care with their fruit and their products they produce.
Tart Cherry Artisan Crisps | Rustic Bakery | Petaluma, CA
Our neighbors at Rustic Bakery are known for their delicious treats and the Tart Cherry, Cacao Nib & Almond crisps are a perfect match for our Winter Club cheese selections. The perfect cheese vehicle!
This is a subscription, with a reoccurring charge every quarter. Each quarter, you’ll receive a different selection of at least three luscious cheeses (with 4 generous servings each), handmade by organic and artisan producers from around Northern California. These collections are chosen to highlight the finest cheeses available each season. We hope that they spark a desire to learn more about artisan and farmstead cheese and share your discoveries with friends and loved ones. Give us a call if you need to reschedule any future delivery. We ship FedEx standard overnight to either your residence or place of work—just let us know which will work best for you!
See our FAQs below
When will my order ship?
Due to the perishable nature of cheese and our standards for the quality of our cheese, we ship via FedEx Overnight Monday - Thursday. Please note the selected ship date is an estimated ship date. All orders will arrive within the selected week on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday or Friday. We cannot guarantee an exact delivery date, so please order in advance for holidays and special occasions.
Click here for more shipping information.
Can I ship to multiple addresses?
Yes! At checkout select “Ship to multiple addresses” and you’ll be able to send each collection to a different address.
How do I add a gift message?
During the checkout, select the checkbox for "include complimentary gift message," and enter your desired greeting. Your complimentary gift message will be printed onto the packing slip that is placed inside the box.
Prices will not be included on the packing slip or inside of the package. Receipts will be sent to the email you entered during checkout.
Can I order individual cheeses?
From our Cheese Shops in the Ferry Building & Point Reyes Station, yes you can.
From our Online Cheese Catalog, we aren’t able to offer individual cheeses. We do feature specific cheeses like our We Love Red Hawk or Welcome Wagon. Also, from time to time, we have online specials with several pieces of the same cheese like our popular Tam Trio. Sign up for our emails in the footer to be the first to know!
How should I store my cheeses?
As soon as you get it home, store the unopened cheese in the refrigerator for best quality. Any opened pieces can be re-wrapped in the cheese paper and sealed in the paper it comes in. You can also re-wrap the cheese in cheese paper that helps to preserve the cheese as much as possible.
If you don’t have cheese paper, use something that will keep the cheese covered so that it doesn’t dry out in the fridge. Other customers have used reusable beeswax food cloths and parchment paper. Plastic wrap can be used, but it’s better for harder cheeses than delicate soft cheese.
Can I create a custom assortment or make substitutions?
For our local fans shopping in San Francisco or visiting us in Point Reyes Station, we offer gift baskets and catering trays.
For our Online Cheese Catalog, unfortunately, we don’t have that option. But check out all of our current catalog - we’ve curated popular combinations that feature the best of Cowgirl for all kinds of cheese lovers.